Thanks for the kind review, Greg. I enjoyed making it and it has really flown out of the beer fridge, as my wife really likes it. This is definately one of those beers that I will make again (I really need to start a list of those, maybe a good thing to keep on my blog). Things I will do next time is to cut back the IBUs just a bit, as the commercial version is a bit softer on the bitterness. With the price of saaz, I will probably again just use those hops for flavor and aroma. Pride of Ringwood has spiked in price lately, so I will try to find a similar floral, spicey hop, that is reasonably priced, to use for bittering.
The other thing I will try is what I heard Jamil say on his podcast, to make the soft mouthfeel character typical of commercial versions of this style, use half RO or DI water and half tap water. It is pretty cheap to buy gallons of the stuff at Walmart or Sams Club, so I think I will try that.
And next time, I will definately be brewing 10 gallons!
Did your wife get to try any? When I left some for Christopher, he later told me he had seriously considered stashing the second bottle away and not sharing. I guess it is time to send Christopher back to kindergarden to learn the importance of sharing . . .